DUP peer Lord Dodds of Duncairn has set out a workable alternative to the Windsor Framework as his European Union (Withdrawal Arrangements) Bill received its second reading in the House of Lords today.
Speaking in the debate, Lord Dodds said:
“The fundamental defects of the Protocol and Windsor Framework have not been resolved. Northern Ireland remains subject to EU law across around 300 areas, imposed without the consent of Parliament or the Assembly. That is a continuing denial of democracy.
A reset which does not remedy our democratic, constitutional and economic problems cannot be regarded as a success. The answer to the denial of democratic rights in one part of our country cannot be to dilute those rights in the rest of it.
We are told these arrangements protect the Belfast Agreement. Yet in December 2024 cross-community consent was cast aside. Every unionist MLA who voted opposed continuing EU law, but it still passed.
The FSB found 58% of businesses trading between GB and NI faced moderate to significant challenges, while over a third had stopped trading rather than face new compliance requirements.
There is an alternative. This Bill is built on mutual enforcement, where each jurisdiction ensures goods exported into the other’s market meet its rules. It was developed by respected European legal experts, including Sir Jonathan Faull. It means no hard border in any direction.
The Government should explain why this cannot be pursued instead of treating the Windsor Framework as the only answer.
The people of Northern Ireland are not asking for preferential treatment. They are asking for equal citizenship.”














