A Letter from Ireland
a Chara,
It seems that for all occasions there is an Oscar Wilde quote. I have developed a seething disregard for some political commentators. You know the type: those who mask cynicism and prejudice with a veneer of informed respectability. Oscar Wilde defined a cynic as someone “who knows the cost of everything and the value of nothing.”
Fine Gael, a party in the Government in Dublin, recently published a blueprint for Irish Unity. This was an informed and welcome development. It included a very lengthy economic appendix examining the cost and benefits of Irish Unity. There will always be a front-end cost to building anything. We normally call those investments. Pay now, reap the benefits later. In recognition of this, Fine Gael has recommended establishing an Irish Unity Sovereign Wealth Fund to meet those costs.
The economic appendix included a potential first-year cost ranging from €3 billion to €25 billion. A range so vast that it is meaningless. Drawing on Oscar’s definition, the cynics in the media latched onto the highest figure to claim the South could not afford the North. Following the logic that Ireland can only be defined by economic contribution, the Western Seaboard, the length of the Wild Atlantic Way, should be handed back to the British because it is a drain on the economy!
There is no ledger that defines what counties should or should not be part of Ireland.
The argument is framed as though the people in the North aren’t quite Irish. Former Taoiseach Leo Varadkar said this week that the partitionist mindset thought of Northerners as “foreigners”. A mindset he wanted to challenge. As a Northerner living in Dublin, it is a reality I have experienced on many occasions.
I was born in Belfast, and I am an Irish Citizen, like my parents and grandparents. We found ourselves on the wrong side of an arbitrary border dividing our Island.
Partition never made economic sense. It has held up economic growth in the border counties and imposed costs on all of Ireland’s trade and infrastructure development. The highest price has been paid in the north with economic decline. Economically, partition doesn’t work.
Ending partition and building a new Ireland is not only the righting of a historic wrong; it is also a project to unlock the Island’s full economic power.
There are those who look at the costs and not the potential and opportunity. Within a few years of German reunification, the new economy had outgrown the sum of its two parts. Germany also demonstrates the need for balanced regional development and not the concentration of jobs and industry in one region. The benefits of unity must be enjoyed by all.
No economists will argue that partition makes economic sense. Yes, there will be a cost; yes, there will be a negotiation with the British, and the Irish job in that negotiation will be to reduce the costs and maximise the benefits.
The people of Ireland know the value of Irish unity outweighs the costs.
Have a great weekend and don’t let the cynics get you down.
Is mise,
Have a great weekend,









